ARTICLE
Auteur(s) : P Poblete-Gutiérrez1, T
Wiederholt2,3, HF Merk2, J Frank1,3
1Department of Dermatology, University Hospital
Maastricht, The Netherlands
2Department of Dermatology, University Hospital of the
RWTH Aachen, Germany
3Porphyria Center, University Hospital of the RWTH
Aachen, Germany
accepté le 29 Septembre 2005
Etiology and mode of inheritance
The porphyrias are metabolic disorders of heme biosynthesis
resulting from a predominantly hereditary catalytic deficiency of
the second to eighth enzyme involved in the porphyrin-heme
biosynthetic pathway (figure 1). Dominantly or
recessively inherited mutations in any of the genes encoding these
enzymes lead to a disturbance of heme synthesis with a pathological
accumulation and measurable excretion of porphyrins and/or
porphyrin precursors [1].
Almost all types of porphyria show a Mendelian inheritance
pattern and result from mutations in the genes outlined in (Table 1), respectively. Porphyria cutanea
tarda (PCT), however, occupies an exceptional position among the
different types of porphyrias since it is the only porphyria in
which an acquired form (PCT type I or sporadic PCT) has to be
distinguished from an inherited variant (PCT type II or hereditary
PCT) [1, 2].
Table 1 Classification of the acute and non-acute
porphyrias highlighting important aspects of each variant
|
Acute porphyrias
|
Gene name and locus
|
Mode of inheritance
|
Important aspects
|
|
Acute intermittent porphyria
|
Porphobilinogen deaminase; 11q24.1-q24.2
|
Autosomal dominant
|
Most common acute porphyria in the world; no skin symptoms
|
|
Variegate porphyria
|
Protoporphyrinogen oxidase; 1q22-23
|
Autosomal dominant
|
Founder mutations identified in South Africa and Chile; skin
symptoms can occur
|
|
Hereditary coproporphyria
|
Coproporphyrinogen oxidase; 3q12
|
Autosomal dominant
|
Rare; skin symptoms can occur
|
|
ALA-D deficiency porphyria
|
ALA dehydratase; 9q34
|
Autosomal recessive
|
Very rare (< 10 cases in the world reported)
|
|
Non-acute porphyrias
|
Gene name and locus
|
Mode of inheritance
|
Important aspects
|
|
Porphyria cutanea tarda
|
Uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase ; 1p34
|
Autosomal dominant
|
Most frequent type of porphyria worldwide; hereditary and acquired
variant exist
|
|
Erythropoietic protoporphyria
|
Ferrochelatase; 18q21.3
|
Autosomal dominant
|
In approximately 5% of the cases severe liver disease can occur;
recessive inheritance has been reported
|
|
Congenital erythropoietic porphyria
|
- Uroporphyrinogen III synthase ;
- 10q25.3-q26.3
|
Autosomal recessive
|
Very severe clinical course; mutilations; hemolytic anemia;
porphyrin deposition in bones and teeth
|
|
Hepatoerythropoietic porphyria
|
Uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase ; 1p34
|
Autosomal recessive
|
Homozygous variant of porphyria cutanea tarda; highly increased
photosensitivity
|
Classification
There are three ways to classify the different types of porphyrias.
Historically, these disorders have been mostly subdivided into
erythropoietic and hepatic forms, according to the major site of
expression of the specific enzymatic deficiency. From a
dermatologist’s perspective, the porphyrias might also be
classified into cutaneous and non-cutaneous forms. However, from
the general clinician’s point of view, it seems most suitable to
classify the porphyrias into acute and non-acute forms, thereby
primarily considering if the patient does or does not experience
potentially life-threatening acute neurological attacks (table 1)
[1]. Therefore, we prefer to adhere to the latter classification
throughout this review.
Non-acute porphyrias
The non-acute porphyrias include Porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT),
erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP), congenital erythropoietic
porphyria (CEP), and hepatoerythropoietic porphyria (HEP), the
recessively inherited variant of PCT (table 1). These types of
porphyria are of specific interest for dermatologists because they
can all reveal cutaneous symptoms on UV light exposed body sites
due to porphyrin deposition in the skin, leading to increased
photosensitivity [1].
Porphyria cutanea tarda
Porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT) (OMIM 176100) is the most frequent
type of porphyria worldwide and results from a decreased catalytic
activity of uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase (URO-D), the fifth
enzyme in heme biosynthesis [1].
According to the major site of expression of URO-D, at least two
types of PCT can be distinguished: a sporadic (acquired) variant,
designated type I PCT, in which the enzymatic deficiency is
exclusively expressed in the liver and a familial (hereditary)
variant, designated type II PCT, in which the catalytic enzymatic
defect is detected in all tissues [1, 2]. Currently, the ratio
between type I and type II PCT is estimated to be approximately 3:1
to 4:1 [1-3] although a recent report indicated that, in some
countries, the frequency of type II PCT might be much higher than
previously estimated [4].
Of note, not every PCT patient with a positive family history
will necessarily be suffering from type II PCT. Recently, Elder
reported several families in which more than one individual was
unequivocally affected with PCT. While these individuals revealed
the typical clinical and biochemical characteristics of overt
disease, normal URO-D activities were measured in red blood cells.
This latter variant of the disease has been designated as type III
PCT and, in sum, there is increasing evidence that some facets of
the etiology of PCT are not completely elucidated yet [5].
The diagnosis of PCT is made on the basis of cutaneous
manifestations, a characteristic urinary porphyrin excretion
profile, and, in some laboratories, by measuring URO-D activities
in red blood cells. The skin findings include increased
photosensitivity due to photosensitization by porphyrins and skin
fragility as well as blistering, erosions, crusts, and miliae on
the sun-exposed areas of the body (figures 2A, 2B and 2C).
Additionally, hyperpigmentation, hypertrichosis, sclerodermoid
plaques (figure
2D), and scarring alopecia can be observed.
Histopathological examination commonly reveals subepidermal,
cell-poor blisters with a characteristic festooning of dermal
papillae that is most likely due to the deposition of PAS-positive
glycoproteins in and around the wall of vessels localized in the
upper dermis. Upon direct immunofluorescence, immunoglobulins
(mainly IgG; less common IgM), complement, and fibrinogen can be
detected at the dermal-epidermal junction and around blood vessels
of the papillary dermis [6]. Regardless of the aforementioned
findings, we would like to emphasize that we consider it
unnecessary, and even contra-indicated, to take a skin biopsy if
one of the cutaneous porphyrias is suspected. First, simple
non-invasive biochemical laboratory techniques can easily prove or
exclude the presumptive diagnosis of porphyria and, second,
external trauma (such as a biopsy or excision) inevitably
constitutes an unnecessary risk for delayed and/or dysfunctional
wound healing.
Biochemically, an increased excretion of uroporphyrin (type I
isomers > type III isomers), 7-carboxyl porphyrins (type III
isomers > type I isomers), and coproporphyrin in the urine and
isocoproporphyrin excretion in the feces can be found.
Enzymatically, URO-D activity is decreased by approximately fifty
percent in red blood cells of individuals suffering from type II
PCT.
A wide range of triggering factors has been reported to
precipitate the clinical manifestation of PCT, among them alcohol,
estrogens, polychlorinated hydrocarbons, hemodialysis in patients
with renal failure, iron, inheritance of specific mutations (C282Y
and H63D) in the HFE gene underlying classic hemochromatosis, and
viral infections such as hepatitis C and HIV [7, 8]. Interestingly,
homozygosity for HFE gene mutation C282Y was found to be associated
with an earlier onset of cutaneous lesions in both sporadic and
familial PCT, the effect being more marked in familial PCT [7].
Further, PCT patients seem to have a higher risk for the
development of hepatocellular carcinoma [1, 8].
Erythropoietic protoporphyria
Erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP) (OMIM 177000) arises from a
usually autosomal dominantly inherited deficiency of ferrochelatase
(FC), the eighth and ultimate enzyme in heme biosynthesis. In
mammals, FC catalyzes the incorporation of ferrous iron
(Fe2+) into protoporphyrin to produce heme.
Biochemically, EPP is characterized by an increase of PP
concentration in erythrocytes, plasma, feces and other tissues,
such as the liver [1, 9].
Clinically, EPP is characterized by cutaneous photosensitivity
with onset early in life. The acute episodes of cutaneous
photosensitivity include burning, stinging, and pruritus in
light-exposed skin, particularly of the nose, cheeks, and dorsal
aspects of the hands. These are followed by erythema, edema,
urticarial lesions, erosions, and wax-like scarring, particularly
on the nose (figures 3A
and 3B). Skin symptoms can occur within minutes of sun
exposure, often starting early in spring time, continuing through
the summer, and diminishing in fall and winter [1, 9].
Histological examination in EPP reveals vacuolization of
epidermal cells. Further, intercellular edema as well as
vacuolization and lysis of endothelial cells of superficial dermal
blood vessels can be seen. If disease activity progresses,
deposition of PAS-positive hyaline material leads to thickening and
degeneration of capillary basement membranes, sometimes resembling
the amorphous protein depositions seen in lipoid proteinosis [10].
Still, we consider it unnecessary to perform a skin biopsy if EPP
is suspected.
Biochemically, EPP is characterized by an increase of free
protoporphyrin in erythrocytes, plasma, feces and other tissues,
such as the liver (Table 2)(Table 3)(Table 4) [1, 9,
10].
The most important concern in EPP patients is the development of
cholestasis with accumulation of protoporphyrin in hepatobiliary
structures and progressive cellular damage resulting in severe
liver disease [11, 12]. Although rarely occurring, progressive
liver failure is now a well recognized complication in EPP. Still,
the pathogenesis of PP-induced hepatic disease is poorly understood
and is rarely diagnosed prior to advanced liver damage.
Recently, the genetic mechanisms in EPP that lead to phenotypic
disease with cutaneous photosensitivity have been characterized. It
is now well understood that only those individuals will develop
skin symptoms who not only inherit a heterozygous FC mutation on
one parental allele in cis but also an intronic FC polymorphism on
the other parental allele in trans [13]. Although these molecular
mechanisms explain the development of increased photosensitivity in
EPP the molecular mechanisms underlying the phenotype with severe
liver injury are still not well understood. Thus, other as yet
unidentified factors may contribute to the pathogenesis and
development of severe liver failure in EPP [14].
Table 2 Biochemical characteristics of the acute
porphyrias in the urine
|
Porphyria type
|
d-aminolevulinic acid
|
Porphobilinogen
|
Uroporphyrin
|
Coproporphyrin
|
|
Variegate porphyria
|
++ to +++
|
++ to +++
|
+++
|
+++
|
|
Hereditary coproporphyria
|
Normal to ++
|
Normal to ++
|
++
|
+++
|
|
Acute intermittent porphyria
|
++ to ++++
|
++ to +++
|
+++
|
++
|
|
ALA-D deficiency-porphyria
|
+++
|
Normal
|
+
|
++
|
Table 3 Biochemical characteristics of the acute
porphyrias in the feces
|
Porphyria type
|
Uroporphyrin
|
Coproporphyrin
|
Protoporphyrin
|
|
Variegate porphyria
|
Normal
|
+++
|
+++
|
|
Hereditary coproporphyria
|
++
|
+++
|
Normal to +
|
|
Acute intermittent porphyria
|
Normal to +
|
Normal to +
|
Normal to +
|
|
ALA-D deficiency-porphyria
|
Normal
|
+
|
+
|
Table 4 Therapy of the non-acute and acute porphyrias
at a glance. While the therapeutic measures in case of an acute
porphyric attack are the same for each variant of the acute
porphyrias, differentiated and individual treatment strategies are
recommended for the non-acute porphyrias depending on the
prevailing symptoms and the respective form of porphyria
|
Non-acute porphyrias
|
Treatment
|
|
Porphyria cutanea tarda
|
1. Photoprotection, e.g. with broad-band sunscreens and/or
protective clothing
|
|
2. Avoidance of sunlight exposure and trauma
|
|
3. Cease alcohol ingestion; stop estrogen therapy
|
|
4. Phlebotomy (venesection): 400-500 mL every two weeks over
~3-6 months
|
|
5. Low-dose chloroquine treatment: 125 mg twice weekly (e.g. on
Monday and Thursday) over 6-12 months, until porphyrin excretion is
within normal range
|
|
6. Laboratory control of urinary porphyrin excretion for monitoring
of therapeutic outcome
|
|
Erythropoietic protoporphyria
|
1. Photoprotection, e.g. with broad-band sunscreens and/or
protective clothing
|
|
2. Avoidance of sunlight exposure (common window glass does not
provide protection)
|
|
3. Oral β-carotene: 30-90 mg/day in children; 60-180 mg/day in
adults. Desirable maximum plasma level: 600–800 μg/dL.
Administration from February to October; pause from November to
January
|
|
Congenital erythropoietic porphyria
|
1. Photoprotection, e.g. with broad-band sunscreens and/or
protective clothing
|
|
2. Strict avoidance of sunlight exposure
|
|
3. Change day-night-rhythm
|
|
4. Splenectomy (reduces hemolysis and platelet consumption)
|
|
5. Bone marrow transplantation
|
|
Hepatoerythropoietic porphyria
|
1. Photoprotection, e.g. with broad-band sunscreens and/or
protective clothing
|
|
2. Strict avoidance of sunlight exposure and trauma
|
|
3. Change day-night-rhythm
|
|
CAUTION – therapeutic approaches used in porphyria cutanea tarda
(phlebotomy; antimalarial) are ineffective!
|
|
Acute porphyrias
|
Treatment
|
|
Acute intermittent porphyria; variegate porphyria; hereditary
coproporphyria; ALA-D deficiency porphyria
|
1. Identification and elimination of precipitating factors
(porphyrinogenic drugs; alcohol; hormones)
|
|
2. Monitoring in intensive care unit and/or contact one of the
porphyria centers
|
|
3. Adequate pain therapy, e.g. with pethidine or other opiate
derivatives
|
|
4. Adequate therapy of nausea and vomiting, e.g. with promazine,
chlorpromazine or triflupromazine
|
|
5. Intravenous administration of heme arginate
(Normosang®) in a dosage of 3 mg/kg bodyweight once a
day as short-time infusion over 4 consecutive days
|
|
6. If necessary, intravenous carbohydrate substitution with glucose
infusions
|
|
7. Laboratory control of urinary porphyrin excretion during the
acute attack (daily, if possible)
|
Congenital erythropoietic porphyria
With approximately 150 cases reported to date, congenital
erythropoietic porphyria (CEP) (OMIM 263700) is an extremely rare,
autosomal recessively inherited condition that results from a
decreased catalytic activity of uroporphyrinogen III synthase the
fourth enzyme in heme biosynthesis. The enzyme is localized in the
cytosol and catalyzes the conversion of the linear tetrapyrrol
hydroxymethylbilane to the cyclic tetrapyrrol uroporphyrinogen III
[1, 15, 16].
CEP manifests shortly after birth with severe cutaneous
photosensitivity that, as the disease progresses, can lead to
blistering, erosions, excoriations, ulceration, and scarring. On
the hands, scarring can lead to deformation and movement
impairment. In the face, loss of eyebrows and eye-lashes as well as
severe mutilation involving cartilage structures, e.g. the nose, is
frequently observed (figure 4A). In addition to
the cutaneous findings, erythrodontia (figure 4B) and a variable
degree of hematological involvement ranging from mild forms of
hemolytic anemia to intrauterine hydrops fetalis as well as
spenomegaly can be found.
Biochemically, an increased excretion of uroporphyrin I and
coproporphyrin I in the urine and elevated levels of coproporphyrin
I in the stool can be found. Upon exposure to sun light, the
accumulation of uroporphyrin I and coproporphyrin I in the bone
marrow, skin, and several other tissues exerts dramatic cytotoxic
effects underlying the cutaneous symptoms.
The diagnosis of CEP is made on the basis of the typical
clinical manifestations, a characteristic porphyrin excretion
profile, and, in some laboratories, by measuring uroporphyrinogen
III synthase activity in red blood cells [17].
Hepatoerythropoietic porphyria
Hepatoerythropoietic porphyria (HEP) (OMIM 176100), the recessive
variant of hereditary PCT, is caused by a drastic deficiency of
URO-D, resulting from homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations
in the URO-D gene [1, 18].
The disease is rare and has only been reported in the United
States of America and Europe. Clinically, HEP usually manifests in
early childhood, with dark urine in the diapers being the most
frequently observed first sign. Subsequently, severe cutaneous
photosensitivity develops that includes blistering, pruritus,
hypertrichosis, hyperpigmentation, and scleroderma-like scarring.
If the clinical course is severe, the disease closely resembles
CEP.
The diagnosis is based on the excretion of elevated urinary
uroporphyrin, hepta-carboxylated porphyrins, elevated fecal
coproporphyrin, and isocoproporphyrin as well as increased levels
of zinc-chelated protoporphyrin in erythrocytes [1].
Differential diagnosis of the non-acute porphyrias
PCT must be distinguished from other types of cutaneous porphyrias
manifesting with blistering. These include mild variants of CEP and
HEP and, in particular, variegate porphyria and hereditary
coproporphyria since the latter two porphyria variants can also
manifest with life-threatening acute attacks. Further,
pseudoporphyria, epidermolysis bullosa acquisita, polymorphous
light eruption, photo-aggravated bullous drug eruptions, and hydroa
vacciniforme have to be ruled out. All aforementioned diseases can
easily be differentiated from PCT by measuring urinary and stool
porphyrins [1, 7, 19].
In EPP, the most important differential diagnoses are dermatitis
solaris, solar urticaria, polymorphous light eruption, and lipoid
proteinosis [1, 10, 19].
CEP has to be differentiated from HEP and the rare homozygous
variants of variegate porphyria; mild variants can sometimes mimic
PCT. Likewise, the most important differential diagnoses of HEP are
CEP and severe forms of PCT. Normally, both CEP and HEP can not be
easily confused with skin diseases other than the porphyrias
[1].
Acute porphyrias
The acute porphyrias comprise acute intermittent porphyria (AIP),
variegate porphyria (VP), hereditary coproporphyria (HCP), and
δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALA-D) deficiency porphyria,
which is also known as plumboporphyria or Doss porphyria (table 1)
[1, 20, 21].
Patients suffering from one of the acute porphyrias might reveal
a broad range of often unspecific clinical symptoms, including
long-lasting colicky abdominal pain, nausea and vomiting, diarrhea,
tachycardia, hypertension, seizures, muscle weakness, paraplegia
and tetraplegia as well as a variety of other neurological and
psychiatric signs. This broad spectrum of often unspecific clinical
symptoms mimicking other diseases demands all diagnostic abilities
of the attending physician particularly since the porphyrias are
rare disorders and, therefore, rarely considered as differential
diagnosis [20, 22].
Acute porphyric attacks can be precipitated by a variety of
factors, including porphyrinogenic drugs, alcohol, hormonal
changes, recurrent or chronic infection, and reduced caloric intake
due to fasting or diets [1, 20, 23].
Apart from the aforementioned neurological findings, individuals
suffering from VP or HCP can also present with cutaneous symptoms
on the sun-exposed areas of the skin, including increased
photosensitivity, abnormal skin vulnerability, blistering,
erosions, scars, and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. Thus, VP
and HCP are also referred to as neurocutaneous porphyrias. By
contrast, however, AIP and ALA-D deficiency porphyria do not
manifest with cutaneous symptoms [1].
In an effort to set forth standards in diagnosis and management
of the acute porphyrias and to provide information and guidelines
for patients as well as physicians, a European consortium of expert
porphyria specialists from different European porphyria centers
founded the European Porphyria Foundation (EPI) in the year 2000.
On the EPI web-page (http://www.porphyria-europe.org), which is
constantly up-dated, important information is available,
particularly if dermatologists and general practitioners are
seeking to contact the nearest porphyria center in their country to
discuss specific problems encountered in the management of their
patients. Furthermore, a comprehensive overview on safe and
potentially unsafe drugs that can be administered or should be
avoided in patients suffering from an acute porphyria can be found.
Motivated by the European expert group, several American porphyria
specialists have recently likewise gathered together in a 24-hour
meeting and, as a result of their meeting, published
recommendations for the diagnosis and treatment of the acute
porphyrias [24].
Acute intermittent porphyria
With the exception of South Africa and Chile, acute intermittent
porphyria (AIP) (OMIM 176000) represents the most frequent type of
acute porphyria throughout the world. This autosomal dominantly
inherited disorder is characterized by a deficiency of
porphobilinogen deaminase, the third enzyme in heme biosynthesis
[1, 25].
In AIP, no cutaneous symptoms occur. Clinically, the disease
usually manifests after puberty with acute porphyric attacks, which
comprise a variety of neurological and/or psychiatric symptoms that
can mimic many other disorders [22]. Signs and symptoms include
abdominal pain, mental disturbances, constipation, diffuse pain,
vomiting, muscle weakness, hypertension, tachycardia, fever,
convulsions, sensory loss, and respiratory paralysis that can lead
to coma and death [1, 25]. These acute attacks might be
precipitated by porphyrinogenic drugs, alcohol ingestion, reduced
caloric intake due to fasting or dieting, infection, and hormones
[23].
Biochemically, elevated urinary levels of the porphyrin
precursors ALA and porphobilinogen (PBG) can be found during an
acute attack, ALA values ranging from five to twenty-fold the
normal levels, and PBG being increased as high as fifty to
hundred-fold the normal range.
Variegate porphyria
Variegate porphyria (VP) (OMIM 176200) is characterized by an
autosomal dominantly inherited deficiency of protoporphyrinogen
oxidase, the seventh enzyme in the pathway of heme biosynthesis [1,
26]. In eukaryotic cells, this enzyme is located on the outer
surface of the inner mitochondrial membrane and catalyzes the
conversion of protoporphyrinogen-IX to protoporphyrin-IX, a process
that requires molecular oxygen [27].
The clinical picture of VP is variable, since cutaneous and
neuropsychiatric symptoms can occur separately or together in
affected individuals [1, 26]. Skin findings include increased skin
fragility and photosensitivity due to photosensitization by
porphyrins. Clinically, these skin findings can not be
differentiated from those observed in PCT (figure 5). Likewise, the
acute attacks observed in VP totally resemble the clinical symptoms
encountered in AIP [20].
The diagnosis is based on elevated urinary levels of ALA and PBG
during acute attacks as encountered in AIP. In phases of remission,
however, ALA and PBG in the urine may be within normal range.
Therefore, additional biochemical analyses of porphyrins in the
feces are mandatory to establish the diagnosis of VP. In the stool,
elevated levels of protoporphyrin and coproporphyrin can be found,
protoporphyrin concentrations usually being higher than those of
coproporphyrin. The latter findings can also be observed in the
phase of remission in between attacks [1, 26].
Hereditary coproporphyria
Hereditary coproporphyria (OMIM 121300) (HCP) is a very rare,
autosomal dominantly inherited variant of the acute porphyrias,
characterized by a deficiency of coproporphyrinogen oxidase, the
sixth enzyme in the porphyrin-heme biosynthetic pathway [1, 28].
The clinical symptoms and biochemical findings are similar to
those described in detail for VP. Biochemically, however, the stool
porphyrin profile commonly reveals coproporphyrin concentrations
higher than those measured for protoporphyrin [28].
δ-Aminolevulinic acid dehydratase deficiency porphyria
This very rare autosomal recessively inherited variant of acute
porphyria is extremely rare. With not more than 7 cases reported
worldwide, δ-aminolevulinic acid dehydratase (ALA-D) deficiency
porphyria does not play an important clinical nor differential
diagnostic role. The disease is also known as plumboporphyria or
Doss porphyria and can manifest early in childhood as well as in
adulthood with an often confusing variety of acute neurological
symptoms that resemble those encountered in AIP [1, 21].
Differential diagnosis of the acute porphyrias
When manifesting with cutaneous symptoms, the differential
diagnoses in both VP and HCP are identical with those of PCT. If
acute neurological attacks prevail, a broad range of
gastrointestinal, neurological, and psychiatric diseases have to be
ruled out, including acute appendicitis and diverticulitis [1, 29].
The latter group of differential diagnoses will not be discussed in
detail here, since emphasis is put on dermatological diseases.
Some of the difficulties and challenges in diagnosis,
prevention, and treatment of the porphyrias will now be
presented.
Diagnostics
The diagnostic procedures involved in making a precise diagnosis of
the prevailing type of porphyria comprise four important sequential
steps [1, 30]:
- – an anamnesis including the frequency of clinical
symptoms and the family history as well as a thorough physical
examination, particularly with regard to skin symptoms on the
sun-exposed sites of the body;
- – a biochemical measurement of porphyrins and porphyrin
precursors in urine and feces (tables 2 and 3). If the presumptive
diagnosis is EPP, the amount of protoporphyrin in erythrocytes has
to be determined, too;
- – determination of specific enzymatic activities in
fibroblasts or lymphocytes, which is usually only possible in
specialized laboratories upon specific indication;
- – mutation analysis using molecular genetic techniques
including DNA isolation from peripheral blood followed by
polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and automated DNA sequencing,
likewise only possible in specialized laboratories.
Difficulties in obtaining a correct diagnosis are primarily due
to the fact that the different types of porphyrias often reveal
overlapping findings with regard to clinical and/or biochemical
features (for diagnostic algorithm see ( figure 6). This is
especially true for VP where cutaneous lesions appear similar to
those observed in PCT and HCP as well as neurovisceral symptoms
similar to those being observed in AIP, HCP, and ALA-D deficiency
porphyria. These symptoms do not necessarily occur universally in
every patient, but some can often be found together in affected
individuals [1, 30].
Concerning biochemical analyses, drastically elevated urinary
levels of the porphyrin precursors ALA and PBG can be found during
an acute attack. However, asymptomatic mutation carriers are rarely
detected by measurement of urinary fecal porphyrin precursors which
often display a high variability and can be just slightly elevated
or normal in the phase between acute attacks. Thus, these methods,
as well as the measurement of enzymatic activities in fibroblasts
or lymphocytes, are somewhat imprecise, since a certain overlap
between the values measured in patients, clinically unaffected gene
carriers (so called “silent” carriers), and normal control
individuals could be found, and the results of the analyses were
not always conclusive [31].
Therefore, the establishment of molecular genetic laboratory
techniques for the identification of underlying mutations on the
basis of direct DNA analysis has been an important contribution to
the traditional diagnostic procedures employed in the different
types of porphyrias [1, 31, 32]. The routine application of such
diagnostic techniques are not only important for clinicians in
obtaining the most precise confirmation of a presumptive diagnosis
but has also enabled molecular biologists and geneticists to learn
more about genes and their function as well as to provide affected
individuals and their family members with genetic counseling [31,
32]. In conclusion, only the combination of all four aforementioned
diagnostic steps will lead to the most accurate diagnosis.
Prevention and therapy
Since the porphyrias are genetic disorders, a causal therapy could
only consist of either enzyme replacement strategies or gene
therapy. However, none of these therapeutic modalities is currently
available for any of the porphyrias. Therefore, the existing
therapeutic concepts in the porphyrias are not always successful
and sometimes merely limited to prophylactic measures and
supportive care [1, 30].
Treatment of the non-acute porphyrias
In general, the avoidance of UV-light exposure, sun-protective
clothing, and regular application of topical sunscreens is crucial,
both prophylactically and therapeutically.
In PCT, triggering factors as e.g. alcohol ingestion and
estrogen therapy should be stopped. Successful treatment can be
achieved by repeated phlebotomy (venesection) of approximately 500
mL blood every two weeks. Some authors recommend weekly
venesections of 300 mL blood. Phlebotomy usually leads to
resolution of skin fragility and blistering within 2-4 months.
However, normalization of urinary porphyrin concentrations will
usually take longer (about 12 months). Chloroquine is thought to
work by accelerating the secretion of porphyrins and may also
inhibit porphyrin synthesis, thereby reducing photosensitivity. The
standard therapy consists of 125 mg chloroquine twice weekly and
complete remission can be expected within 6-9 months (table 4).
Chloroquine and phlebotomy can be used in combination to induce
faster remission [1, 33]. Of note, a recent report indicates that
the genetic background of PCT patients with regard to the presence
of HFE gene mutations plays a critical role in the outcome of
chloroquine treatment. Whereas heterozygosity for mutation C282Y
and compound heterozygosity of HFE mutations did not compromise the
therapeutic response to chloroquine, PCT patients homozygous for
C282Y seem to retain high serum iron, ferritin, and transferrin
saturation and, most importantly, failed to respond to chloroquine
therapy [34].
In EPP, beta-carotene has proven to minimize burning, stinging
and photosensitivity reactions in approximately 60% of the
patients. Although it has no effect on protoporphyrin levels in
erythrocytes it reduces photosensitivity through quenching the
formation of free radicals during the cutaneous photoreaction.
Beta-carotene should be administered preferably from February to
October with a pause between November and January. The doses
administered range from 30-90 mg/day in children and 60-180 mg/day
in adults with desirable maximum plasma levels of approximately
600-800 μg/dL. Single reports exist on therapeutic attempts with
cysteine or narrow-band UVB-phototherapy but the usefulness of
these treatment modalities has so far not been convincingly
demonstrated [1, 10, 30].
In CEP, surveillance of anemia and skin infections is crucial.
Frequent blood transfusions can suppress erythropoiesis thereby
decreasing porphyrin production and photosensitivity. Concomittant
administration of deferoxamine can reduce the resulting
iron-overload. If successful, bone marrow transplantation leads to
marked reduction of porphyrin levels and photosensitivity and has
been reported to be curative CEP [1, 15, 30].
Apart from thorough photoprotection, no specific treatment
options are currently available for HEP. An overview on current
therapeutic strategies in the non-acute porphyrias is given in
table 4.
Treatment of the acute porphyrias
Therapy of the cutaneous symptoms
In both VP and HCP, avoidance of UV-light exposure, sun-protective
clothing, and regular application of topical sunscreens is
mandatory. In contrast to PCT, phlebotomy seems to be of no
benefit. Although it is conceivable that anti-malarials such as
chloroquine might be helpful in decreasing photosensitivity in VP
and HCP, too, chloroquine and its derivatives belong to the group
of porphyrinogenic drugs known as potential inducers of acute
porphyric attacks. Thus, the use of chloroquine in the treatment of
cutaneous symptoms in VP or HCP cannot be recommended.
Therapy of an acute porphyric attack
An acute porphyric attack is a life-threatening event that requires
immediate intervention. Whereas formerly an acute porphyric crisis
displayed a significant mortality that could be as high as 10%, it
is estimated that due to modern therapeutic options the mortality
rate has nowadays decreased to approximately 2%. Likewise,
complications such as paralysis, respiratory failure, and coma can
be effectively prevented by early therapeutic intervention [1, 20,
35].
Therapy of an acute porphyric attack should comprise three
consecutive measures.
- 1. The administration of suspicious porphyrinogenic
drugs should be ceased immediately and, if necessary, patients
should be admitted to an intensive care unit.
- 2. Neurological symptoms like abdominal pain and
vomiting should be treated symptomatically. However, one should
keep in mind that any administration of drugs in a patient with
acute porphyria certainly carries the risk of triggering or
prolonging an acute attack. Thus, several guidelines have been
previously published suggesting so called “safe” and “unsafe” drugs
to be used or avoided in the treatment of an acute porphyric attack
[1, 23]. In addition to guidelines previously published in medical
journals and textbooks, extensive information about drugs and their
safety in patients with acute porphyria can also be found on the
web site of the EPI at http://www.porphyria-europe.org.
- 3. The most important therapeutic step is the early
intravenous administration of heme arginate
(Normosang®). Since the early 1970s, acute attacks have
been treated with hematin preparations [36]. These hematin
preparations had the disadvantage of being very unstable. Further,
thrombophlebitis as an adverse effect was reported in a high
percentage of patients treated [37, 38].
Heme arginate is composed of human hemin and L-arginine as an
additive to increase the solubility and stability of the product.
In contrast to the older hematin preparations, heme arginate does
not induce any significant changes in coagulation and fibrinolysis
and the frequency of thrombophlebitis as well as the overall rate
of side effects is markedly reduced [38, 39]. Heme arginate is
administered as a short-time (15-20 minutes) infusion in a dosage
of 3 mg/kg bodyweight/day over a period of four days. In
exceptional cases, heme arginate administration can be prolonged up
to seven days if the acute attack does not cease. However, it is
not recommended to use heme arginate for more than seven days. In
Europe, heme arginate (Normosang®) is available from
Orphan Europe, www.orphan-europe.com, in cases of emergency,
usually even within 24 hours, if requested. If heme arginate is not
immediately available, the time span can be bridged by initiating
adjuvant intravenous glucose infusions.
An overview on current therapeutic strategies in the acute
porphyrias is given in table 4.
Conclusions and future prospects
Establishing the diagnosis of porphyria can be difficult because
the different types often reveal uncharacteristic clinical symptoms
and overlapping biochemical findings. These difficulties are most
obvious in VP and HCP where cutaneous lesions appear similar to
those found in PCT as well as neurological symptoms mimicking many
other diseases and particularly those encountered in the most
common type of acute porphyria, AIP.
The biggest challenge with regard to biochemical analyses is the
identification of clinically asymptomatic mutation carriers, in
particular children before puberty. These so called “silent
carriers” are only rarely detected by the traditional measurement
of urinary and/or fecal porphyrins and porphyrin precursors which
often display a high variability. These biochemical methods, as
well as the measurement of enzymatic activities in fibroblasts or
lymphocytes, are somewhat imprecise, since a certain overlap
between the values measured in patients, clinically unaffected
silent carriers, and normal control individuals was reported to
occur. Thus, these analyses were not always conclusive [31,
40].
However, the recent progress in the field of molecular genetics
and the accomplishments of the Human Genome Project have provided
clinicians and medical researchers with permanently advancing
molecular biological techniques and novel insights into the
complexity of genetic disorders. These modern genetic techniques
nowadays enable us to transfer our clinical observations and
biochemical data to the laboratory bench for diagnostic
complementation by PCR based DNA testing. Understanding the
molecular basis of the porphyrias is essential for genetic
engineering and the development of gene therapy strategies that
will not only serve those suffering from porphyria but eventually
also be of benefit for patients with different genetic disorders.
The advancing progress in basic science has made an invaluable
contribution to the rapid translation of discoveries made today in
the laboratory into new diagnostics and therapeutics in the near
future.
References
1 Bickers DR, Frank J. The porphyrias. In:
Fitzpatrick TB, Freedberg IM, Eisen AZ,
Wolff K, Austen KF, Goldsmith LA, Katz SI, eds.
Dermatology in general medicine, edition 6. McGraw Hill, 2003:
1435-66.
2 de Verneuil H, Aitken G, Nordmann Y. Familial
and sporadic porphyria cutanea: two different diseases. Hum Genet
1978; 44: 145-51.
3 Elder GH, Roberts AG, de Salamanca RE. Genetics
and pathogenesis of human uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase defects.
Clin Biochem 1989; 22: 163-8.
4 Poblete-Gutierrez P, Mendez M, Wiederholt T,
Merk HF, Fontanellas A, Wolff C, Frank J. The
molecular basis of porphyria cutanea tarda in Chile: identification
and functional characterization of mutations in the
uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase gene. Exp Dermatol 2004; 13:
372-9.
5 Elder GH. Human URO-D defects. In: Orfanos CE,
Stadler R, Gollnick H, eds. Dermatology in five
continents. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1988: 857-60.
6 Kolanko E, Bickle K, Keehn C, Glass LF.
Subepidermal blistering disorders: a clinical and histopathologic
review. Semin Cutan Med Surg 2004; 23: 10-8.
7 Brady JJ, Jackson HA, Roberts AG,
Morgan RR, Whatley SD, Rowlands GL, Darby C,
Shudell E, Watson R, Paiker J, Worwood MW,
Elder GH. Co-inheritance of mutations in the uroporphyrinogen
decarboxylase and hemochromatosis genes accelerates the onset of
porphyria cutanea tarda. J Invest Dermatol 2000; 115: 868-74.
8 Armas R, Krause P, Wolff C. Porphyria cutanea
tarda, chronic liver disease caused by the C virus and
hepatocarcinoma. Clinical case. Rev Med Chil 1994; 122: 72-4.
9 Cox TM. Erytthropoietic protoporphyria. J Inherit Metab
Dis 1997; 20: 258-69.
10 Lecha M. Erythropoietic protoporphyria. Photodermatol
Photoimmunol Photomed 2003; 19: 142-6.
11 Frank M, Doss OD. Severe liver disease in
protoporphyria. In: Vermeer BJ, Wuepper KD, van
Vloten WA, Baart de la Faille H, van der
Schoroeff JG, eds. Curr Probl Dermatol, Volume 20. Karger,
1991: 160-7.
12 Mercurio MG, Prince G, Weber FL,
Jacobs G, Zaim MT, Bickers DR. Terminal hepatic
failure in erythropoietic protoporphyria. J Am Acad Dermatol 1993;
29: 829-33.
13 Gouya L, Puy H, Robreau AM, et al. The
penetrance of dominant erythropoietic protoporphyria is modulated
by expression of wildtype FECH. Nat Med 2002; 30: 27-8.
14 Navarro S, Del Hoyo P, Campos Y,
Abitbol M, Moran-Jimenez MJ, Garcia-Bravo M,
Ochoa P, Grau M, Montagutelli X, Frank J,
Garesse R, Arenas J, de Salamanca RE,
Fontanellas A. Increased mitochondrial respiratory chain
enzyme activities correlate with minor extent of liver damage in
mice suffering from erythropoietic protoporphyria. Exp Dermatol
2005; 14: 26-33.
15 Desnick RJ, Astrin KH. Congenital erythropoietic
porphyria: advances in pathogenesis and treatment. Br J Haematol
2002; 117: 779-95.
16 Fritsch C, Lang K, Bolsen K, Lehmann P,
Ruzicka T. Congenital erythropoietic porphyria. Skin Pharmacol
Appl Skin Physiol 1998; 11: 347-57.
17 Tsai SF, Bishop DF, Desnick RJ. Coupled-enzyme
and direct assays for uroporphyrinogen III synthase activity in
human erythrocytes and cultured lymphoblasts. Enzymatic diagnosis
of heterozygotes and homozygotes with congenital erythropoietic
porphyria. Anal Biochem 1987; 166: 120-33.
18 Elder GH, Roberts AG. Uroporphyrinogen
decarboxylase. J Bioenerg Biomembr 1995; 27: 207-14.
19 Murphy GM. Diseases associated with photosensitivity. J
Photochem Photobiol B 2001; 64: 93-8.
20 Poblete Gutiérrez P, Kunitz O, Wolff C,
Frank J. Diagnosis and treatment of the acute porphyrias: An
interdisciplinary challenge. Skin Pharmacol Appl Skin Physiol 2001;
14: 393-400.
21 Doss M, von Tiepermann R, Schneider J,
Schmid H. New type of hepatic porphyria with porphobilinogen
synthase defect and intermittent acute clinical manifestation. Klin
Wochenschr 1979; 57: 1123-7.
22 Crimlisk HL. The little imitator-porphyria: a
neuropsychiatric disorder. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1997; 62:
319-28.
23 Moore MR, Hift RJ. Drugs in the acute porphyrias:
Toxicogenetic diseases. Cell Mol Biol 1997; 43: 89-94.
24 Anderson KE, Bloomer JR, Bonkovsky HL,
Kushner JP, Pierach CA, Pimstone NR,
Desnick RJ. Recommendations for the diagnosis and treatment of
the acute porphyrias. Ann Intern Med 2005; 142: 439-50.
25 Kauppinen R, von und zu Fraunberg M. Molecular and
biochemical studies of acute intermittent porphyria in 196 patients
and their families. Clin Chem 2002; 48: 1891-900.
26 Frank J, Christiano AM. Variegate porphyria: past,
present and future. Skin Pharmacol Appl Skin Physiol 1998; 11:
310-20.
27 Deybach JC, da Silva V, Grandchamp B,
Nordmann Y. The mitochondrial location of protoporphyrinogen
oxidase. Eur J Biochem 1995; 149: 431-5.
28 Martasek P. Hereditary coproporphyria. Semin Liver Dis
1998; 18: 25-32.
29 Holmann JR, Green JB. Acute intermittent porphyria.
More than just abdominal pain. Postgrad Med 1989; 86: 295-8.
30 Kauppinen R. Porphyrias. Lancet 2005; 365: 241-52.
31 Grandchamp B, Puy H, Lamoril J,
Deybach JC, Nordmann Y. Review: molecular pathogenesis of
hepatic acute porphyrias. Gastroenterol Hepatol 1996; 11:
1046-52.
32 Frank J, Christiano AM. The genetic bases of the
porphyrias. Skin Pharmacol Appl Skin Physiol 1998; 11: 297-309.
33 Sarkany RPE. The management of porphyria cutanea tarda.
Clin Exp Dermatol 2001; 26: 225-32.
34 Stölzel U, Köstler E, Schuppan D,
Richter M, Wollina U, Doss MO, Wittekind C,
Tannapfel A. Hemochromatosis (HFE) gene mutations and response
to chloroquine in porphyria cutanea tarda. Arch Dermatol 2003; 139:
309-13.
35 Thunell S, Harper P, Brock A,
Petersen NE. Porphyrins, porphyrin metabolism and porphyrias.
II. Diagnosis and monitoring in the acute porphyrias. Scand J Clin
Lab Invest 2000; 60: 541-59.
36 Dhar GJ, Bossenmaier I, Petryka ZJ,
Cardinal R, Watson CJ. Effects of hematin in hepatic
porphyria. Further studies. Ann Intern Med 1975; 83: 20-30.
37 Goetsch CA, Bissell DM. Instability of hematin used
in the treatment of acute hepatic porphyria. N Engl J Med 1986;
315: 235-8.
38 Tenhunen R, Mustajoki P. Acute porphyria: treatment
with heme. Semin Liver Dis 1998; 18: 53-5.
39 Mustajoki P, Nordmann Y. Early administration of
heme arginate for acute porphyric attacks. Arch Intern Med 1993;
153: 2004-8.
40 Da Silva V, Simonin S, Deybach JC, Puy H,
Nordmann Y. Variegate porphyria: diagnostic value of
fluorometric scanning of plasma porphyrins. Clin Chim Acta 1995;
238: 163-8.
|